patching...
Breaking: Woman Robbed, Burglarized at Home; County Seeking Help Finding Suspect »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Judge Rejects Joliet Diocese Birth Control Suit

The diocese, joined by Catholic Charities and the Springfield diocese, wanted to be exempt from a mandate that it must provide employee insurance that funds birth control and sterilization.

 

A lawsuit seeking to exempt the Catholic Diocese of Joliet and others from having to comply with a federal law mandating that its employee health insurance cover contraception and sterilization costs has been rejected by a federal judge.

The diocese, which was joined in the suit by the Diocese of Springfield and Catholic Charities in Chicago, Joliet and Springfield, argued that the mandate violated the organizations' 1st Amendment rights guaranteeing religious freedom.

According to a story published by the Catholic Conference of Illlinois, U.S. Judge John Darrow's ruling rejected the organizations' arguments.

"Darrah stated the plaintiffs have no standing since religious organizations have been granted a 'safe harbor' until Aug. 1, 2013 to implement the required insurance coverage," the story said.

"He also stated that the lawsuit is not ripe for adjudication since the plaintiffs have not yet suffered any harm from the mandate."

Related Topics: 1st Amendment rights freedom of religion, contraceptives sterilization, diocese of joliet, federal mandate on employee health insurance, and lawsuit rejected

mohammed@aol.com

3:20 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013

You reporting is very suspect . The court did not reject the case but refused to hear it because 1 ) the mandate does not go into effect until August 1 and ; 2 ) there is no evidence to-date currently that any harm has been incurred. The suit can and probably will be revived AFTER August 1 . Your reporting is Hype

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Karen Sorensen

5:36 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Actually, he didn't refuse to hear it, he dismissed it. I think we're playing game of semantics because the end result is the same: the case has been kicked out and will not be tried. Because it was dismissed "without prejudice," it can be refiled and may very well be if "harm" can be proven, as you noted. I provided a link to the actual ruling in the story, and I'll include it here, too, so readers can judge for themselves. www.ilcatholic.org/wp-content/uploads/HHS_Lawsuit_Dismissal_-Springfield_Joliet_ChicagoCC02082013.pdf

ALLEN KURTZ

5:00 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Does the church throw out people in there parish for using birth control ?: Does the church let people still marry after divorced ? Does the church throw anyone out of the church for working on sundays ?: The church is just a bunch of hypercrits.
Its all about $$$$$$$$$$$$$

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Fuerte

12:02 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Allen -

The church believes in if you play you pay. Abstinance is the #1 way of birth control. If you must utilize other ways of it, they look down on it, however you will not be thrown out because you use it. The church lets you get married, if you are divorced, if an annulment is granted! Marriage is supposed to be a commitment, not taken lightly...and it is until "death do you part". The church doesn't throw anyone out for working on Sundays, although it is your obligation to practice your faith, that is why they have some churches with late night mass schedules and Saturdays for all. Please learn about these things before you start talking smack!

Comment_arrow

Phillip Cleary

8:38 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Allen? The point is that the Government is forcing the church to perform acts that go against the Roman Catholic doctrine. It isn't about money as much as it is about Separation of State and Church. If the Church can't interfere with Government then Government can't interfere with the Church doctrine.

anonymous

9:09 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Obama is the anti-Christ. And if you think the govt will not someday mandate everything you people say and do then you are dumber than I thought. Allen -your spelling and grammar reflects your ignorance.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Olddeegee

10:03 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Your superstitions reflect your ignorance.

Comment_arrow

ALLEN KURTZ

11:27 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013

be careful space ships are coming to get you

Comment_arrow

Susan Fuerte

11:56 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013

and this is why you posted anonymous....chicken?

Comment_arrow

John Roberts

1:20 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Some people who said the British would come and try to take everything over,Some of the people who said that the Union would attack,Some of the people who spoke out against hitler and said he would attack if given the chance..Were all called parinoid of government also...it's not a paranoia of government it is just not keeping quiet nor ignoring how much power the U.S. government has been given....Now anti-Christ and all that stuff makes the point lost...even people who choose not to believe in a god know the power of the government...It is just unreal to not at least keep that in the back of your mind..and also know that every single government that was ever installed from the beginnings of Neanderthals who grouped up to governments installed today ALL have battled their citizens in a form of dicipline/enslavement or to change policies...we are all human and because we chose to follow the laws of man and not follow instincts sometimes is the effect of the sheep being lead to the slaughter house..Time has told this story time and time again....Which is why today so many people are calling for removal of some politicians,and such drastic government change..But the electoral collage is installed to make sure the "People Never " can really vote by popularity or by choice..and only have a president today to protect political corruption otherwise things would of changed a long time ago..Iceland threw out their system and arrested bankers,Judges and Politicians...A real Change.

anonymous

1:15 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Everyone here is the kind of person that gladly lets a TSA agent grope their kids at the airport.

Reply
Comment_arrow

John Roberts

1:29 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Lmao that's the way it seems don't it...seems that government talk is for only certain people in certain places,during certain times,...and not supposed to be talked about by the common person but to only sendall of our kids to fight the wars,battles that the government likes to get into...other wise your parinoid....how dare people talk about the government issues....your just supposed to say "Go America" not question...ya start to learn that when your a kid going to church not to question..and the government just eats it up....they know it's creating stupid people...who will all be standing with a dumb founded look on their faces if something was to happen..while the rest of us will have expected it...It's not Government against its people..it's stupid people doing stupid things causing more people to beg and demand government to do something...What can they do? pass a law and use violence to enforce it...

anonymous

1:35 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Careful JR- with the NDAA the Prex doesn't need a trial to "get rid of"problems with US citizens.

Reply
Comment_arrow

John Roberts

1:54 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Yep fully aware..and Obama wouldn't tell congress nor the courts if he was using the law before it was found constitutional or not...but it's all just paranoia to the people that let another man or woman decide what's right for them...the people who listen to another human being like that human talks to god themselves...It will only change when it's in the best interests of both...NDAA,CISPA,SOPA.....To these people that's all government talk were not supposed to question.....To me you should question everything and if you believe in it then you should question it Even More....

Susan Fuerte

2:28 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Then if you are not happy, why not leave and go to a disserted island and be the president of your own island, we are all in this together....when we die, hopefully you believe in an afterlife better than this one, that has been promised to you! "Don't fix your eyes to this world, long for what is in the next life to come!"

Reply

Leave a comment